9743432034586385cfef87df4b377c255ed0cba8 Fix bug where duplicate PSBT keys are accepted (John L. Jegutanis)
Pull request description:
As per the BIP 174 spec a PSBT key cannot be duplicated,
however the current code accepts key duplication.
The PSBT key/value entries can be duplicated when the value
is `empty()` or `IsNull()` for `CScript` or `CTxOut` respectively
and if those key/value entries are serialized before the non-empty ones.
For example, the following PSBT, included in the test vectors,
contains a duplicate field:
```
// magic
70736274ff
// global tx
//// key
0100
//// value
2a02000000000140420f000000000017a9146e91b72d5593e7d4391e2ff44e91e985c31641f08700000000
//// separator
00
// no inputs
// outputs
//// key PSBT_OUT_WITNESSSCRIPT
0101
//// value (empty script)
00
//// key PSBT_OUT_WITNESSSCRIPT (same as the above)
0101
//// value (an OP_RETURN script)
016a
//// separator
00
```
ACKs for top commit:
achow101:
ACK 9743432034586385cfef87df4b377c255ed0cba8
instagibbs:
code review ACK 9743432034
Tree-SHA512: 34f4b34c8e6561c6a6ab745cdd319f6687eac6f7cecc735c94035eeca8c5157e17a27f2ae853dbaa6634fcd5a8f4e1c6cc13d1ebd7e563459665d72bb147cc1e
fa25f43ac5692082dba3f90456c501eb08f1b75c p2p: Remove BIP61 reject messages (MarcoFalke)
Pull request description:
Reject messages (BIP 61) appear in the following settings:
* Parsing of reject messages (in case `-debug=net` is set, off by default). This has only been used for a single `LogPrint` call for several releases now. Such logging is completely meaningless to us and should thus be removed.
* The sending of reject messages (in case `-enablebip61` is set, off by default). This can be used to debug a node that is under our control. Instead of hacking this debugging into the p2p protocol, it could be more easily achieved by parsing the debug log. (Use `-printtoconsole` to have it as stream, or read from the `debug.log` file like our python function `assert_debug_log` in the test framework does)
Having to maintain all of this logic and code to accommodate debugging, which can be achieved by other means a lot easier, is a burden. It makes review on net processing changes a lot harder, since the reject message logic has to be carried around without introducing any errors or DOS vectors.
ACKs for top commit:
jnewbery:
utACK fa25f43ac5692082dba3f90456c501eb08f1b75c
laanwj:
I'm still not 100% convinced that I like getting rid of BIP61 conceptually, but apparently everyone wants it, code review ACK fa25f43ac5692082dba3f90456c501eb08f1b75c.
ryanofsky:
Code review ACK fa25f43ac5692082dba3f90456c501eb08f1b75c
Tree-SHA512: daf55254202925e56be3d6cfb3c1c804e7a82cecb1dd1e5bd7b472bae989fd68ac4f21ec53fc46751353056fd645f7f877bebcb0b40920257991423a3d99e0be
4bb660be90a2811b53855bf1fd33a8dd9ba3db47 Add release note (Andrew Chow)
ed96b295d747738334459490c79b7360ab85aaf7 Update descriptors.md to include sortedmulti (Andrew Chow)
80be78ea75ac9833ee3db3d468ed09fc4fe6274c Test sortedmulti descriptor using BIP 67 tests (Andrew Chow)
6f588fd2276e5b713c6d36e3b01288484ddb59c0 Add sortedmulti descriptor and unit tests (Andrew Chow)
Pull request description:
Adds a `sortedmulti()` descriptor as mentioned in https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/17023#issuecomment-537596416.
`sortedmulti()` works in the same way as `multi` does but sorts the pubkeys in the resulting scripts in lexicographic order as described in [BIP67](https://github.com/bitcoin/bips/blob/master/bip-0067.mediawiki). Note that this does not add support for BIP67 nor is BIP67 fully supported by this descriptor (which is why it is not named `multi67()`) as it does not require compressed pubkeys.
Tests from BIP67 were added and documentation was updated.
ACKs for top commit:
instagibbs:
re-ACK 4bb660be90
Sjors:
re-ACK 4bb660be90a2811b53855bf1fd33a8dd9ba3db47
Tree-SHA512: 93b21112a74ebe0bf316d8f3e0291f69fd975cf0a29332f9728e7b880cad312b8b14007e86adcd7899f117b9303cbcf4cb35f3bb2f2f648d1a446f83f75a70a5
8acd58927a614e006641384f61f8e7fca1cc68fc Fix Python Docstring to include all Args. (John Bampton)
Pull request description:
Found a Python function that had incorrect and missing arguments in its Docstring.
ACKs for top commit:
laanwj:
ACK 8acd58927a614e006641384f61f8e7fca1cc68fc
Tree-SHA512: 936f275f29a700d630bb479b5283e47b66f2df76d8b8c053f594e6aedf783cc98a29c924c3a46613f112dfc884acb50f21a0b18f96d939e887b12b921ef2e10f
As per the BIP 174 spec a PSBT key cannot be duplicated,
however the current code accepts key duplication.
The PSBT key/value entries can be duplicated when the value
is `empty()` or `IsNull()` for `CScript` or `CTxOut` respectively
and if those key/value entries are serialized before the non-empty ones.
For example, the following PSBT, included in the test vectors,
contains a duplicate field:
```
// magic
70736274ff
// global tx
//// key
0100
//// value
2a02000000000140420f000000000017a9146e91b72d5593e7d4391e2ff44e91e985c31641f08700000000
//// separator
00
// no inputs
// outputs
//// key PSBT_OUT_WITNESSSCRIPT
0101
//// value (empty script)
00
//// key PSBT_OUT_WITNESSSCRIPT (same as the above)
0101
//// value (an OP_RETURN script)
016a
//// separator
00
```
ea4cc3a7b36a9c77dbf0aff439da3ef0ea58e6e4 Truly decouple wallet from chainparams for -fallbackfee (Jorge Timón)
Pull request description:
Before it was 0 by default for main and 20000 for test and regtest.
Now it is 0 by default for all chains, thus there's no need to call Params().
Also now the default for main is properly documented.
Suggestion for release notes:
-fallbackfee was 0 (disabled) by default for the main chain, but 20000 by default for the test chains. Now it is 0 by default for all chains. Testnet and regtest users will have to add fallbackfee=20000 to their configuration if they weren't setting it and they want it to keep working like before.
Should I propose them to the wiki for the release notes or only after merge?
For more context, see https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/16402#issuecomment-515701042
ACKs for top commit:
MarcoFalke:
ACK ea4cc3a7b36a9c77dbf0aff439da3ef0ea58e6e4
Tree-SHA512: fdfaba5d813da4221e405e0988bef44f3856d10f897a94f9614386d14b7716f4326ab8a6646e26d41ef3f4fa61b936191e216b1b605e9ab0520b0657fc162e6c
Before it was 0 by default for main and 20000 for test and regtest.
Now it is 0 by default for all chains, thus there's no need to call Params().
Also now the default for main is properly documented
faec689bed7a5b66e2a7675853d10205b933cec8 txmempool: Make entry time type-safe (std::chrono) (MarcoFalke)
faaa1f01daba94b021ca77515266a16d27f0364e util: Add count_seconds time helper (MarcoFalke)
1111170f2f0141084b5b4ed565b2f07eba48599a test: mempool entry time is persisted (MarcoFalke)
Pull request description:
This changes the type of the entry time of txs into the mempool from `int64_t` to `std::chrono::seconds`.
The benefits:
* Documents the type for developers
* Type violations result in compile errors
* After compilation, the two are equivalent (at no run time cost)
ACKs for top commit:
ajtowns:
utACK faec689bed7a5b66e2a7675853d10205b933cec8
laanwj:
ACK faec689bed7a5b66e2a7675853d10205b933cec8
Tree-SHA512: d958e058755d1a1d54cef536a8b30a11cc502b7df0d6ecf84a0ab1d38bc8105a67668a99cd5087a444f6de2421238111c5fca133cdf8e2e2273cb12cb6957845
c812aba3949b6ab81030dc708cda7c8821be2f70 test bumpfee fee_rate argument (ezegom)
9f25de3d9eb8d012ca1a98cbcd28021e3e1c85ee rpc bumpfee check fee_rate argument (ezegom)
88e5f997dfab3f03bb1ec3f149eaff8dcc2981fe rpc bumpfee: add fee_rate argument (ezegom)
1a4c791cf49ff15aa9deba4388c0180b8f47f15b rpc bumpfee: move feerate estimation logic into separate method (ezegom)
Pull request description:
Taking over for https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/16492 which seems to have gone inactive.
Only minor commit cleanups, rebase, and some help text fixes on top of previous PR. Renamed `feeRate` to `fee_rate` to reflect updated guidelines.
ACKs for top commit:
Sjors:
Code review ACK c812aba
laanwj:
ACK c812aba3949b6ab81030dc708cda7c8821be2f70
Tree-SHA512: 5f7f51bd780a573ccef1ccd72b0faf3e5d143f6551060a667560c5163f7d9480e17e73775d1d7bcac0463f3b6b4328f0cff7b27e39483bddc42a530f4583ce30
1a02edb3f2803b6f82f06a31acf0b0e5fc19bd1c [RPC] Fix casing in getblockchaininfo to be inline with the rest of the response (Dan Gershony)
Pull request description:
The response in the RPC result `startTime` is camel cased while the rest of the response seems to be lower cased.
If this was intentional please ignore and close this PR.
Note: RPC field case changes might break existing callers
ACKs for top commit:
laanwj:
ACK 1a02edb3f2803b6f82f06a31acf0b0e5fc19bd1c
Tree-SHA512: 6f0eaf2b4aaf73c9a9bf1fbd4af59af5f95fc012fa88f94e050e6ae273b3ad647f5729df53bfce91e1a925fe4fd7b14818908bb6131a81413a555137d1007d7c
The response in the RPC result `starttime` is camel cased while the rest of the response seems to be lower cased.
If this was intentional please ignore this PR.
Note: case might break existing callers
Reflect the change in the test data
Change to snake case
6659810e2f38994813aa9d7644d570ae0152fa2c test: use named args for sendrawtransaction calls (Jon Atack)
5c1cd78b7e582660a78d9d9dec673967a6b78936 doc: improve rawtransaction code/test docs (Jon Atack)
acc14c50932c7353f94d3d4367d05021606e0ca9 test: fix incorrect value in rpc_rawtransaction.py (Jon Atack)
Pull request description:
Follow-up to PR #16521.
- Fix incorrect value in rpc_rawtransaction test as per https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/16521/files#r325842308
- Improve the code docs
- Use named arguments as per https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/16521/files#r310715127
Happy to squash or keep only the first commit if the others are too fixup-y.
ACKs for top commit:
laanwj:
ACK 6659810e2f38994813aa9d7644d570ae0152fa2c
Tree-SHA512: bf5258f23802ab3ba3defb8791097e08e63f3e2af21023f832cd270dc88d1fa04349e921d69f9f5fedac5dce5cd3c1cc46b48febbede4bc18dccb8be994565b2
fa69588537bc91c0aedbc89ef1760d89cbffad75 test: Make PORT_MIN in test runner configurable (MarcoFalke)
Pull request description:
This is needed when some ports in the port range are used by other processes. Note that simply assigning the ports dynamically does not work:
* We spin up several nodes per test (each node gets its own port)
* We run several tests in parallel
So to avoid nodes from different tests colliding on ports, the port assignment must be deterministic (can not be dynamic).
Fixes: #10869
ACKs for top commit:
practicalswift:
ACK fa69588537bc91c0aedbc89ef1760d89cbffad75 -- diff looks correct
promag:
ACK fa69588537bc91c0aedbc89ef1760d89cbffad75.
Tree-SHA512: e79adb015e7de79064e2d14336c38bc9672bd779ad6c52917721897e73f617c39d32c068a369c26670002a6c4ab95a71ef3a6878ebdd9710e02f410e2f7bcd14
fa2e038691263ddd107df233148d9814630d4a18 test: Fix extra_args in wallet_import_rescan.py (MarcoFalke)
Pull request description:
Bug introduced by me (🤦♂️) in fa25668e1c8982548f1c6f94780709c625811469
For reference:
```
>>> a = [[]]*2
>>> a[0] += ['ONE']
>>> a
[['ONE'], ['ONE']]
>>> a = [[] for _ in range(2)]
>>> a[0] += ['ONE']
>>> a
[['ONE'], []]
ACKs for top commit:
theStack:
utACK fa2e038
Tree-SHA512: 7d75a0d06233d013d62198ea95793612242254d5d90f393d01b2beef5abc78d6e85c796532311638f16cfed3b66a7ae41a108c0fe6f0f5d7f6616b042c670df7
c4b0c08f7c91bcef48dd023982ff132795575247 Update tx-size-small comment with relevant CVE disclosure (Gregory Sanders)
Pull request description:
Code first introduced under https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/11423 with essentially no description and no discussion.
ACKs for top commit:
MarcoFalke:
ACK c4b0c08f7c91bcef48dd023982ff132795575247
fanquake:
ACK c4b0c08f7c91bcef48dd023982ff132795575247
Tree-SHA512: 95d5c92998b8b1e944c477dbaee265b62612b6e815099ab31d9ff580b4dff777abaf7f326a284644709f918aa1510412d62310689b1250ef6e64de7b19ca9f71
fadfd844de8c53034a97dfa6f771ffe9f523fba2 test: Remove unused connect_nodes_bi (MarcoFalke)
fa3b9ee8b2280af4bcbcfffff275aaf8dd125929 scripted-diff: test: Replace connect_nodes_bi with connect_nodes (MarcoFalke)
faaee1e39a91b3f603881655d3980c29af09852b test: Use connect_nodes when connecting nodes in the test_framework (MarcoFalke)
1111bb91f517838e5b9f778bf6b5a9c8d561e857 test: Reformat python imports to aid scripted diff (MarcoFalke)
Pull request description:
By default all test nodes are connected in a chain. However, instead of just a single connection between each pair of nodes, we end up with up to four connections for a "middle" node (two outbound, two inbound, from each side).
This is generally redundant (tx and block relay should succeed with just a single connection) and confusing. For example, test timeouts after a call to `sync_` may be racy and hard to reproduce. On top of that, the test `debug.log`s are hard to read because txs and block invs may be relayed on the same connection multiple times.
Fix this by inlining `connect_nodes_bi` in the two tests that need it, and then replace it with a single `connect_nodes` in all other tests.
Historic background:
`connect_nodes_bi` has been introduced as a (temporary?) workaround for bug #5113 and #5138, which has long been fixed in #5157 and #5662.
ACKs for top commit:
laanwj:
ACK fadfd844de8c53034a97dfa6f771ffe9f523fba2
jonasschnelli:
utACK fadfd844de8c53034a97dfa6f771ffe9f523fba2 - more of less a cleanup PR.
promag:
Tested ACK fadfd844de8c53034a97dfa6f771ffe9f523fba2, ran extended tests.
Tree-SHA512: 2d027a8fd150749c071b64438a0a78ec922178628a7dbb89fd1212b0fa34febd451798c940101155d3617c0426c2c4865174147709894f1f1bb6cfa336aa7e24
2dfd6834ef8737e16e4b96df0c459f30a0721d6c test: Add test for default maxfeerate in sendrawtransaction (Joonmo Yang)
261843e4bef96ab296a9775819a99bfa60cad743 wallet/rpc: Use the default maxfeerate value as BTC/kB (Joonmo Yang)
Pull request description:
Fixes https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/issues/16382
This patch tries to treat `maxfeerate` in sendrawtransaction/testmempoolaccept RPC as a rate(BTC/kB) instead of an absolute value(BTC).
The included test case checks if the new behavior works correctly, by using the transaction with an absolute fee of ~0.02BTC, where the fee rate is ~0.2BTC/kB.
This test should be failing if the default `maxfeerate` is 0.1BTC, but pass if the default value is 0.1BTC/kB
ACKs for top commit:
laanwj:
ACK 2dfd6834ef8737e16e4b96df0c459f30a0721d6c (ACKs by Sjors and MarcoFalke above for trivially different code)
Tree-SHA512: a1795bffe8a182acef8844797955db1f60bb0c0ded97148f3572dc265234d5219271a3a7aa0b6418a43f73b2b2720ef7412ba169c99bb1cdcac52051f537d6af
c0b5d9710322a614a50ab5da081558cf6a38ad2a Test that joinpsbts randomly shuffles the inputs (Andrew Chow)
6f405a1d3b38395e35571b68aae55cae50e0762a Shuffle inputs and outputs after joining psbts (Andrew Chow)
Pull request description:
`joinpsbts` currently just adds the inputs and outputs in the order of that the PSBTs were provided. This makes it extremely easy to identify which outputs belong to which inputs. This PR changes that so that all of the inputs and outputs are shuffled in the joined transaction.
ACKs for top commit:
instagibbs:
utACK c0b5d97103
jonatack:
ACK c0b5d9710322a614a50ab5da081558cf6a38ad2a modulo suggestions for later.
Tree-SHA512: 14a0b7aae07d92e6d2c76a3a3b228b481e1964cb7d34f97515bdda18e2ea05a9f97c5a22affc143b86ae8b95c3cb239849fb54219d65512bc2112264dca915c8
0c62e3aa73839e97e65a3155e06a98d84b700a1e New regression testing for CVE-2018-17144, CVE-2012-2459, and CVE-2010-5137. (lucash-dev)
38bfca6bb2ad68719415e9c54a981441052da072 Added comments referencing multiple CVEs in tests and production code. (lucash-dev)
Pull request description:
This functional test includes two scenarios that test for regressions of vulnerabilities, but they are only briefly described. There are freely available documents explaining in detail the issues, but without explicit mentions, the developer trying to maintain the code needs an additional step of digging in commit history and PR conversations to figure it out.
Added comments to explicitly mention CVE-2018-17144 and CVE-2012-2459, for more complete documentation.
This improves developer experience by making understanding the tests easier.
ACKs for top commit:
laanwj:
ACK 0c62e3aa73839e97e65a3155e06a98d84b700a1e, checked the CVE numbers, thanks for adding documentation
Tree-SHA512: 3ee05351745193b8b959e4a25d50f25a693b2d24b0732ed53cf7d5882df40b5dd0f1877bd5c69cffb921d4a7acf9deb3cc1160b96dc730d9b5984151ad06b7c9
ae0add8dfe23310e10f18732dbd54360ce405b9b Add python bech32 impl round-trip test (Gregory Sanders)
Pull request description:
Currently there is a single use of `segwit_addr.encode`, and zero uses of `segwit_addr.decode` in the codebase.
This adds a simple round-trip test of the implementation to avoid future regressions.
Top commit has no ACKs.
Tree-SHA512: feb3303f240f5987993e092ec15b878c8db3957d338db6a08fbe947bbfea0c558c7ebc26f8052c38a69d85c354f24e71431e19e0a2991c3c64b604f6d50697ff
2222c96deec0f636dee6e49efb745f29b06a40a5 test: Add notes on how to generate data/wallets/high_minversion (MarcoFalke)
Pull request description:
I forgot to do this in #16796
ACKs for top commit:
ryanofsky:
ACK 2222c96deec0f636dee6e49efb745f29b06a40a5
Tree-SHA512: 5f24ffa641b97eac4febad42ade7228b14fa72335c918a10880c5dec86a3ecc3075a31526f275188e07fea95b8e2c6320c64f716099f604b00e13d5366fcee37
fae961de6be3e2ab9793d437079651541e219e71 test: Establish only one connection between nodes in rpc_invalidateblock (MarcoFalke)
Pull request description:
Headers and block sync should eventually converge to the same result, regardless of whether the peers treat each other as "inbound" or "outbound".
`connect_nodes_bi` has been introduced as a (temporary?) workaround for bug #5113 and #5138, which has long been fixed in #5157 and #5662.
Thus remove the `connect_nodes_bi` workaround from the rpc_invalidateblock test.
Conveniently, this also closes#16453. See https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/issues/16444#issuecomment-514801708 for rationale
ACKs for top commit:
laanwj:
ACK fae961de6be3e2ab9793d437079651541e219e71
Tree-SHA512: b3614c66a205823df73f64d19cacfbec269beb5db52ff79004d746e17d7c0dfb43ab9785fdddc97e2a76fe76286c8c605b34df3dda4a2bf5be035f01169ae89a
- Test gettransaction response without verbose, with verbose=False, and with verbose=True.
- In each case, test presence of expected fields in the output, including absence of the "decoded" field when `verbose` is not passed or false.
- Test that the "details" field contains the expected receive vout in each case.
