faff2ba4f80fad5af63a31559fd4065e631a8166 Remove reindex special case from the progress bar label (MarcoFalke)
Pull request description:
The user knows which option they passed to the program, so it seems overly verbose to offer the user feedback whether or not they passed `-reindex`. Treat it as `DISK`, like all other cases that are treated as `DISK`:
* `-reindex-chainstate`
* `-loadblock`
ACKs for top commit:
john-moffett:
Re-ACK faff2ba4f80fad5af63a31559fd4065e631a8166
hebasto:
ACK faff2ba4f80fad5af63a31559fd4065e631a8166, I have reviewed the code and it looks OK, I agree it can be merged.
Tree-SHA512: 7f110c4beb1451d26f32da3a60150dac91c8a7b8d1c01749017204712b73cc1b77578af492930e4b6704097a73ed051f77bc39d8f60e0ff15a797a201805312e
1914e470e327091c625f627b4447beb336f7fe5a build: copy config.{guess,sub} post autogen in zmq package (fanquake)
Pull request description:
Otherwise our config.guess and config.sub will be copied over. This problem has been masked by the fact that modern systems ship with versions that recognise all the triplets we use (namely arm64-apple-darwin). However building on ubuntu 20.04 surfaces the issue.
Fixes#26420.
ACKs for top commit:
hebasto:
ACK 1914e470e327091c625f627b4447beb336f7fe5a, tested on Ubuntu 18.04.
Tree-SHA512: dff64c3c62d9f8fc205e5a4dffe8befd58838418d073a15dfe304a0f64b182dfffd9dcf98b53df44bfab905c12a62d03cd5c0f91fa7c4b246ac21ae5f20540fd
c9ba4f9ecb1a282d98e7456a84ca84362b161757 test: Add test for file system permissions (Hennadii Stepanov)
581f16ef3404274cb5c1a79dd3d6ee7b584f9844 Apply default umask in `SetupEnvironment()` (Hennadii Stepanov)
8a6219e54379911605aed860519e0194f1433b72 Remove `-sysperms` option (Hennadii Stepanov)
Pull request description:
On master (1e7564eca8a688f39c75540877ec3bdfdde766b1) docs say:
```
$ ./src/bitcoind -help | grep -A 3 sysperms
-sysperms
Create new files with system default permissions, instead of umask 077
(only effective with disabled wallet functionality)
```
Basing on that, one could expect that running `bitcoind` first time will create data directory and `wallets/` subdirectory with safe 0700 permissions.
But that is not the case:
```
$ stat .bitcoin | grep id
Access: (0775/drwxrwxr-x) Uid: ( 1000/ hebasto) Gid: ( 1000/ hebasto)
$ stat .bitcoin/wallets | grep id
Access: (0775/drwxrwxr-x) Uid: ( 1000/ hebasto) Gid: ( 1000/ hebasto)
```
Both directories, in fact, are created with system default permissions.
With this PR:
```
$ stat .bitcoin/wallets | grep id
Access: (0700/drwx------) Uid: ( 1000/ hebasto) Gid: ( 1000/ hebasto)
$ stat .bitcoin/wallets | grep id
Access: (0700/drwx------) Uid: ( 1000/ hebasto) Gid: ( 1000/ hebasto)
```
---
This PR:
- is alternative to bitcoin/bitcoin#13389
- fixesbitcoin/bitcoin#15902
- fixesbitcoin/bitcoin#22595
- closesbitcoin/bitcoin#13371
- reverts bitcoin/bitcoin#4286
Changes in behavior: removed `-sysperms` command-line argument / configure option. The related discussions are here:
- https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/13389#issuecomment-395306690
- https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/13389#issuecomment-539906114
- https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/13389#discussion_r279160472
If users rely on non-default access permissions, they could use `chmod`.
ACKs for top commit:
john-moffett:
ACK c9ba4f9ecb1a282d98e7456a84ca84362b161757
willcl-ark:
ACK c9ba4f9ecb1a282d98e7456a84ca84362b161757
Tree-SHA512: 96c745339e6bd0e4d7bf65daf9a721e2e1945b2b0ab74ca0f66576d0dc358b5de8eb8cdb89fe2160f3b19c39d2798bb8b291784316085dc73a27102d3415bd57
1c07500dbb6b93510425c8bbdb320f2533efdb3d contrib: make DNS seeds file an argument in CLI (brunoerg)
Pull request description:
Instead of using `makeseeds.py` this way:
```sh
python3 makeseeds.py -a asmap-filled.dat < seeds_main.txt > nodes_main.txt
```
We could use the DNS seeds file as an argument since it is a required one. It improves the way the script handles it when that file is missing as well as makes this script more friendly.
E.g:
```sh
python3 makeseeds.py -a asmap-filled.dat -s seeds_main.txt > nodes_main.txt
```
ACKs for top commit:
vincenzopalazzo:
ACK 1c07500dbb
Tree-SHA512: bddf728d5d376659155f5bbeb1fa0d42aa273ec4a0cf5687f4d3f3be85625f541d392f30008e3c9d2c65967cb882deb36af34330994727771be73c9adeb521e0
935acdcc79d1dc5ac04a83b92e5919ddbfa29329 refactor: modernize the implementation of uint256.* (pasta)
Pull request description:
- Constructors of uint256 to utilize Span instead of requiring a std::vector
- converts m_data into a std::array
- Prefers using `WIDTH` instead of `sizeof(m_data)`
- make all the things constexpr
- replace C style functions with c++ equivalents
- memset -> std::fill
This may also be replaced by std::memset, but I think that std::fill is more idiomatic of modern c++ and readable.
- memcpy -> std::copy
Note: In practice, implementations of std::copy avoid multiple assignments and use bulk copy functions such as std::memmove if the value type is TriviallyCopyable and the iterator types satisfy LegacyContiguousIterator. (https://en.cppreference.com/w/cpp/algorithm/copy)
This could also likely be replaced by std::memcpy, but as said above, I believe the using std::copy is the more c++ way to do anything and is almost guaranteed to compile to the same asm
- memcmp -> std::memcmp
ACKs for top commit:
achow101:
ACK 935acdcc79d1dc5ac04a83b92e5919ddbfa29329
hebasto:
Approach ACK 935acdcc79d1dc5ac04a83b92e5919ddbfa29329.
aureleoules:
reACK 935acdcc79d1dc5ac04a83b92e5919ddbfa29329
john-moffett:
ACK 935acdcc79d1dc5ac04a83b92e5919ddbfa29329
stickies-v:
Approach ACK 935acdcc7
Tree-SHA512: 4f1ba54ff2198eea0e505d41e73d552c84c60f6878d5c85a94a8ab57f39afc94ef8d79258e7afd01fa84ec2a99f4404bb877eecd671f65e1ee9273f3129fc650
b8032293e67a3b61ecad531412be5330f7cb39e3 Remove use of snprintf and simplify (John Moffett)
Pull request description:
These are the only remaining uses of `snprintf` in our project, and they can cause unexpected issues -- for example, see https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/issues/27014. Change them to use our `ToString` (which uses a locale-independent version of `std::to_string`) to convert an `int` to `std::string`. Also remove resulting unused parts of `StringContentsSerializer`.
Closes https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/issues/27014
ACKs for top commit:
Sjors:
tACK b8032293e67a3b61ecad531412be5330f7cb39e3, fixes#27014.
Tree-SHA512: c903977e654711929decafe8887d0de13b38a340d7082875acc5d41950d834dcfde074e9cabecaf5f9a760f62c34322297b4b156af29761650ef5803b1a54b59
82f895d7b540ae421f80305a4f7cbb42905fb2c6 Update nanobench to version v4.3.10 (Martin Leitner-Ankerl)
Pull request description:
Nothing has changed that would affect Bitcoin's usage of nanobench.
Here is a detailed list of the changes
* Plenty of clang-tidy updates
* documentation updates
* faster Rng::shuffle
* Enable perf counters on older kernels
* Raise default minimum epoch time to 1ms (doesn't effect bitcoin's usage)
* Add support for custom information per benchmark
ACKs for top commit:
hebasto:
ACK 82f895d7b540ae421f80305a4f7cbb42905fb2c6, I've reviewed the code, all related changes from #26642 have been implemented.
Tree-SHA512: 942518398809a2794617a347ab8182b784a8e822e84de5af078b2531eabb438412d687cac22a21936585e60e07138a89b41c28c9750744c05a3d1053f55cad01
fe683f352480245add0b27fe7efef5fef4c1e8c3 log: Log VerifyDB Progress over multiple lines (Martin Zumsande)
61431e3a57b5613d8715c93c6eae0058e0217eaa validation: Skip VerifyDB checks of level >=3 if dbcache is too small (Martin Zumsande)
Pull request description:
This is the first two commits from #25574, leaving out all changes to `-verifychain` error-handling :
- The Problem of [25563](https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/issues/25563) is that when we skip blocks at level 3 due to an insufficient dbcache (skipping some `DisconnectBlock()` calls), we would still attempt the level 4 checks, attempting to reconnect a block that was never disconnected, leading to an assert in `ConnectBlock()`.
Fix this by not attempting level 4 checks in this case.
- Logging of verification progress is now split over multiple lines. This is more verbose, but now each update has its own timestamp, and other threads logging concurrently will no longer lead to mangled output.
This can be tested with a small `dbcache` value, for example:
`bitcoind -signet -dbcache=10`
`bitcoin-cli -signet verifychain 4 1000`
Fixes#25563
ACKs for top commit:
MarcoFalke:
review ACK fe683f352480245add0b27fe7efef5fef4c1e8c3 🗄
john-moffett:
ACK fe683f352480245add0b27fe7efef5fef4c1e8c3
Tree-SHA512: 3e2e0f8b73cbc518a0fa17912c1956da437787aab95001c110b01048472e0dfe4783c44df22bd903d198069dd2f6b02bfdf74e0b934c7a776f144c2e86cb818a
6699d850e466a65ddd0802be747188ef40cf9de0 doc: release notes for #27037 (Antoine Poinsot)
dfc9acbf0170bde6f2abb879b5584dabd1266531 rpc: decode Miniscript descriptor when possible in decodescript (Antoine Poinsot)
Pull request description:
The descriptor inference logic would previously always use a dummy signing provider and would never analyze the witness script of a P2WSH scriptPubKey.
It's often not possible to infer a Miniscript only from the onchain Script, but it was such a low hanging fruit that it's probably worth having it?
Fixes https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/issues/27007. I think it also closes https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/issues/25606.
ACKs for top commit:
instagibbs:
ACK 6699d850e4
achow101:
ACK 6699d850e466a65ddd0802be747188ef40cf9de0
sipa:
utACK 6699d850e466a65ddd0802be747188ef40cf9de0
Tree-SHA512: e592bf1ad45497e7bd58c26b33cd9d05bb3007f1e987bee773d26013c3824e1b394fe4903809d80997d5ba66616cc79d77850cd7e7f847a0efb2211c59466982
fdb8dc8a5a10c39927dc4b8ddc5e0038a633c50e gui: Show watchonly balance only for Legacy wallets (Andrew Chow)
Pull request description:
Descriptor wallets do not have a watchonly balance as wallets are designated watchonly or not. Thus we should not be displaying the empty watchonly balance for descriptor wallets.
The result is that instead of the send page showing "Watch-only balance: 0.00000000 BTC" for watchonly descriptor wallets, we see the actual balance as "Balance: 10.00000000 BTC"
ACKs for top commit:
johnny9:
tACK fdb8dc8a5a10c39927dc4b8ddc5e0038a633c50e
furszy:
ACK fdb8dc8a
hebasto:
ACK fdb8dc8a5a10c39927dc4b8ddc5e0038a633c50e
Tree-SHA512: e5c0703a62d25c881c8dadfb9cffd482791f3d437a4ec5ae0088ce1a2069c2455ad6d3ec6c95a4404a3b55fbd727f92694529c35052236951553ca90c4ed31b5
c497a198db6f417d2612078a9fbc101e259fab33 Fix comment about how wallet txs are sorted (John Moffett)
Pull request description:
The wallet transactions in the node are not sorted by txid (or any hash) since https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/24699.
This is how they're stored in memory now:
835212cd1d/src/wallet/wallet.h (L397-L399)
ACKs for top commit:
achow101:
ACK c497a198db6f417d2612078a9fbc101e259fab33
jarolrod:
ACK c497a198db6f417d2612078a9fbc101e259fab33
Tree-SHA512: e72559991688452ef254474d4235dc75fac655bce04909c3a0eece907360f4c6f57707db9b4373a4bd2271b23c57e863684c33e0728adf48e477c5499cdfdad7
One test case uses snprintf to convert an
int to a string. Change it to use ToString
(which uses a locale-independent version of
std::to_string). Also remove unnecessary
parts of StringContentsSerializer.
The descriptor inference logic would previously always use a dummy
signing provider and would never analyze the witness script of a P2WSH
scriptPubKey.
Note even a valid Miniscript might not always be decodable from Script
without more contextual information (for instance the key preimage for a
pk_h).
b093f5619f8f9b7d63ee60ff04de00b907b13d64 Fill out dust limit unit test for known types except bare multisig (Greg Sanders)
Pull request description:
Having the constants checked explicitly in a single spot helps with possible regressions and also useful for documentation.
In addition, add a check for undefined v1 witness programs.
ACKs for top commit:
theStack:
Code-review ACK b093f5619f8f9b7d63ee60ff04de00b907b13d64
MarcoFalke:
review ACK b093f5619f8f9b7d63ee60ff04de00b907b13d64 🥉
Tree-SHA512: 1421f75471739d29b9ef59b0a925b6b07e4e9af92822dbe56eedfb590be9a00fb0c34312146c7c1b5211906461ed00bfa2eb53c88595c6e5a27694b2dc21df38
Nothing has changed that would affect Bitcoin's usage of nanobench. Here is a detailed list of the changes
* Plenty of clang-tidy updates
* documentation updates
* faster Rng::shuffle
* Enable perf counters on older kernels
* Raise default minimum epoch time to 1ms (doesn't effect bitcoin's usage)
* Add support for custom information per benchmark
fab9f7d1bd48198d3e0d3c3a08e404ea73a2bc8d test: Use std::unique_ptr over manual delete in coins_tests (MarcoFalke)
Pull request description:
Makes the code smaller and easier to read
ACKs for top commit:
stickies-v:
ACK fab9f7d1bd48198d3e0d3c3a08e404ea73a2bc8d
john-moffett:
ACK fab9f7d1bd48198d3e0d3c3a08e404ea73a2bc8d
Tree-SHA512: 30d2d2097906e61fdef47a52fc6a0c5ce2417bc41c3c82dafc1b216c655f31dabf9c1c13759575a696f61bbdfdba3f442be032d5e5145b7a54fae2a927824621
fa6986a66b451f532a1aa2bd72c956fcd8c0d042 ci: Print iwyu patch in git diff format (MarcoFalke)
Pull request description:
Seems more dev friendly to also have a patch to copy-paste
ACKs for top commit:
hebasto:
ACK fa6986a66b451f532a1aa2bd72c956fcd8c0d042, tested on Ubuntu 22.04 locally.
fanquake:
ACK fa6986a66b451f532a1aa2bd72c956fcd8c0d042 - did not test but example CI output looks ok.
stickies-v:
utACK fa6986a66b451f532a1aa2bd72c956fcd8c0d042
Tree-SHA512: 7cfd8584bf12e03c28af23f4712c6bcafd648d87ddb92788b9cd35455b2db49f4bd4aef8ad4711f75c7f11ad2bb2492c2eb6044007086c20e36016575c060603
fa486de212108b4609d7c247d2a578f0b4df9703 ci: Cache package manager install step (MarcoFalke)
Pull request description:
Use the local podman or docker image cache to skip the slow `apt` step
ACKs for top commit:
jamesob:
ACK fa486de212108b4609d7c247d2a578f0b4df9703 ([`jamesob/ackr/26976.1.MarcoFalke.ci_cache_package_manager`](https://github.com/jamesob/bitcoin/tree/ackr/26976.1.MarcoFalke.ci_cache_package_manager))
Tree-SHA512: 3495346c6c862b63296d2691cc492bf52a0a99ee7fae798887c792609904546013eba788045cd508a5f669f2c52e3479c122c18a5275c87af38237a1b5c9da17
576f7b86147447215566f0b15ef0b56cd1282929 Fix misleading RPC console wallet message (John Moffett)
Pull request description:
## Misleading message from RPCConsole window ##
In certain circumstances, the GUI console will display the message 'Executing command without any wallet' when it is, in fact, using the currently loaded wallet. For instance:
In RPC calls, if no wallet is explicitly selected and there is exactly one wallet loaded, the [default](39363a4b94/src/wallet/rpc/util.cpp (L71-L93)) is to act on that loaded wallet.
The GUI console acts that way in reality, but sometimes erroneously reports that it's not acting on any particular wallet. The root issue is due to the logic that prevents changing the selected wallet if the RPCConsole is visible:
39363a4b94/src/qt/rpcconsole.cpp (L783-L786)
This PR removes that unnecessary logic. This does have some ramifications. Prior to this PR, if a user opened the console window without any wallets loaded, then opened two or more wallets, the RPC console would select "None" of the wallets and any wallet-specific RPCs would fail. However, the behavior was different if the user hadn't had the console window open. In that case, if they opened the RPC Console window _after_ loading at least the first wallet, it would select the first-loaded wallet. This context-dependent behavior is (IMO) undesirable, and this PR changes it to be consistent.
ACKs for top commit:
hebasto:
ACK 576f7b86147447215566f0b15ef0b56cd1282929, tested on Ubuntu 22.04 (Qt 5.15.3).
Tree-SHA512: 627da186025ba4f4e8df7fdd1b10363f923c4ecc50f023bbf2aece6e2593da65c45147c933effaca9040f813a6e46f034fc2d1ee2fb0f401000a3a6221a0e36e
08209c039ff4ca5be4982da7a2ab7a624117ce1a Correctly limit overview transaction list (John Moffett)
Pull request description:
Fixes#703
The way the main overview page limits the number of transactions displayed (currently 5) is not an appropriate use of Qt. Our subclassed transaction sort/filter proxy model returns a maximum of `5` in `rowCount()`. However, the model itself actually may hold significantly more. While this has _worked_, it breaks the contract of `rowCount()`.
If `bitcoin-qt` is run with a DEBUG build of Qt, it'll result in an assert-crash in certain relatively common situations (see #703 for details). Instead of artificially limiting the `rowCount()` in the subclassed filter, we can hide/unhide the rows in the displaying `QListView` upon any changes in the sorted proxy filter.
I loaded a wallet with 20,000 transactions and did not notice any performance differences between master and this branch.
For reference, this is the list I'm referring to:
<img width="934" alt="image" src="https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/116917595/214947304-3f289380-3510-487b-80e8-d19428cf2f0f.png">
ACKs for top commit:
Sjors:
tACK 08209c039ff4ca5be4982da7a2ab7a624117ce1a
hebasto:
ACK 08209c039ff4ca5be4982da7a2ab7a624117ce1a, tested on Ubuntu 22.04.
Tree-SHA512: c2a7b1a2a6e6ff30694830d7c722274c4c47494a81ce9ef25f8e5587c24871b02343969f4437507693d4fd40ba7a212702b159cf54b3357d8d76c02bc8245113
fa47b28dfc2a6577519e10da68ebd8da93568434 refactor: Remove unused CDataStream SerializeMany constructor (MarcoFalke)
Pull request description:
Seems odd to have an unused method. Moreover, the function is fragile and dangerous, because one could have a `std::vector vec_a` and type `CDataStream{vec_a, 0, 0}.size()` and `CDataStream{0, 0, vec_a}.size()`, assuming they are the same thing, when in fact they are not. (The first takes over the memory as is, the second serializes the vector).
So my suggestion would be to remove the unused method and introduce a new method when this functionality is needed. For example: `static DataStream FromMany(Args&&... args)`.
ACKs for top commit:
stickies-v:
ACK fa47b28dfc2a6577519e10da68ebd8da93568434
Tree-SHA512: 9593a034b997e33a0794f779f76f02425b1097b218cf8cb1facb7f874fa69da328ce567a79138015baeebe004ae7d103dda4f64f83e8ad375b6dae6b66d3d950
fad7af700e3f57d16631e27fbe2fd7aaa6c9a950 Use steady clock for logging timer (MarcoFalke)
Pull request description:
The logging timer has many issues:
* The underlying clock is mockable, meaning that benchmarks are useless when mocktime was set at the beginning or end of the benchmark.
* The underlying clock is not monotonic, meaning that benchmarks are useless when the system time was changed during the benchmark.
Fix all issues in this patch.
ACKs for top commit:
stickies-v:
Approach ACK fad7af700e3f57d16631e27fbe2fd7aaa6c9a950
john-moffett:
ACK fad7af700e3f57d16631e27fbe2fd7aaa6c9a950
Tree-SHA512: bec8da0f338ed4611e1807937575e1b2afda25139d88015b1c29fa7d13946fbfbc4ee589b576c0508d505df5e5fafafcbc07d63ce4bab4b01475260d9d5d2107
71383f2fad065378393ef55b6d65e14c656b7301 ci: avoid using -Werror for older compilers (fanquake)
Pull request description:
Don't enable `-Werror` (in the CI) for compilers at least older than our current release compiler (GCC 10). It provides little-to-no value, other than turning compiler bugs & false positives into build failures, and we aren't going to mutate perfectly fine/working code, for the sake of avoid a warning that shouldn't even exist.
I also do not see the point of playing whack-a-mole and turning off various warnings/trying to further work around the broken compiler, just to acheive warningless builds for the sake of warningless builds.
One anecdote from ["How SQLite Is Tested"](https://www.sqlite.org/testing.html):
> Static analysis has found a few bugs in SQLite, but those are the
> exceptions. More bugs have been introduced into SQLite while trying
> to get it to compile without warnings than have been found by static
> analysis.
ACKs for top commit:
hebasto:
ACK 71383f2fad065378393ef55b6d65e14c656b7301
jarolrod:
ACK 71383f2fad065378393ef55b6d65e14c656b7301
Tree-SHA512: 20ed3dcf54fb17a7d9f0d8ca68c0ad2ee8f171f8bd61673a428f3123ab322c24cd9833f65915489bc8cebeffc37fd683a30e9669684b219960e69ddc7adae5bd
6d31900e52efa2c7c7a220d8c8ad6353c412a2aa wallet: migrate wallet, exit early if no legacy data exist (furszy)
Pull request description:
The process first creates a backup file then return an error,
without removing the recently created file, when notices that
the db is already running sqlite.
ACKs for top commit:
john-moffett:
ACK 6d31900e52efa2c7c7a220d8c8ad6353c412a2aa
achow101:
ACK 6d31900e52efa2c7c7a220d8c8ad6353c412a2aa
ishaanam:
crACK 6d31900e52efa2c7c7a220d8c8ad6353c412a2aa
Tree-SHA512: 9fb52e80de96e129487ab91bef13647bc4570a782003b1e37940e2a00ca26283fd24ad39bdb63a984ae0a56140b518fd0d74aa2fc59ab04405b2c179b7d3c54a
dc70c1eb08ba8f0e77ac0810312a67468ade9419 addrman: Use std::nullopt instead of {} (Martin Zumsande)
59cc66abb945c11f30fa571899127275528c5fce test: Remove AddrMan unit test that fails consistency checks (Martin Zumsande)
Pull request description:
Two fixups for #26847:
* Now that `AddrMan::Size()` performs internal consistency tests (it didn't before), we can't call it in the `load_addrman_corrupted` unit tests, where we deal with an artificially corrupted `AddrMan`. This would fail the test when using `-checkaddrman=1` (leading to spurious CI fails). Therefore remove the tests assertion, which is not particularly helpful anyway (in production we abort init when peers.dat is corrupted instead of querying AddrMan in its corrupted state).
(See https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/26847#issuecomment-1411458339)
* Use `std::nullopt` instead of `{}` for default args (suggested in https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/26847#discussion_r1090643603)
ACKs for top commit:
MarcoFalke:
lgtm ACK dc70c1eb08ba8f0e77ac0810312a67468ade9419
Tree-SHA512: dd8a988e23d71a66d3dd30560bb653c9ad17db6915abfa5f722818b0ab18921051ec9223bfbc75d967df8bcd204dfe473d680bf68e8a8e4e4998fbb91dc973c5
fa451d4b60ee0538b3ea6b946740a64734b35b6d Fix clang-tidy readability-const-return-type violations (MarcoFalke)
Pull request description:
This comes up during review, so instead of wasting review cycles on this, just enforce it via CI
ACKs for top commit:
stickies-v:
utACK fa451d4b6
hebasto:
ACK fa451d4b60ee0538b3ea6b946740a64734b35b6d.
Tree-SHA512: 144a85612f00ec43f7ea1fdaa11901ca981a9f0465a8849745712d741b201b9c3307118172ee0b8efd12bebf25bc6f32a6e2c908495e371f9ada0a917994f44e
Don't enable `-Werror` (in the CI) for compilers at least older than
our current release compiler (GCC 10). It provides little-to-no value,
other than turning compiler bugs & false positives into build failures,
and we aren't going to mutate perfectly fine/working code, for the sake
of avoid a warning that shouldn't even exist.
I also do not see the point of playing whack-a-mole and turning off various
warnings/trying to further work around the broken compiler, just to
acheive warningless builds for the sake of warningless builds.
One anecdote from "How SQLite Is Tested":
> Static analysis has found a few bugs in SQLite, but those are the
> exceptions. More bugs have been introduced into SQLite while trying
> to get it to compile without warnings than have been found by static
> analysis.
https://www.sqlite.org/testing.html.
Now that Size() performs internal consistency checks,
it will rightfully fail (and assert) when dealing with
a corrupted AddrMan. Therefore remove this check.
87f11ef47fea31d51bcc3f5df68f78fb28e3d8dd refactor: use `Hash` helper for double-SHA256 calculations (Sebastian Falbesoner)
Pull request description:
We have two helper templates `Hash(const T& in1)` and `Hash(const T& in1, const T& in2)` available for calculating the double-SHA256 hash of one object or two concatenated objects, respectively:
b5868f4b1f/src/hash.h (L74-L89)
This PR uses them in order to increase readability and simplify the code. As in #15294 (which inspired this PR, doing the same for RIPEMD160), the helper is not utilized in validation.cpp and script/interpreter.cpp to avoid touching consensus-relevant code.
ACKs for top commit:
john-moffett:
ACK 87f11ef47fea31d51bcc3f5df68f78fb28e3d8dd
stickies-v:
ACK 87f11ef47fea31d51bcc3f5df68f78fb28e3d8dd
MarcoFalke:
review ACK 87f11ef47fea31d51bcc3f5df68f78fb28e3d8dd 😬
Tree-SHA512: 11d7e3d00c89685107784010fbffb33ccafb4d1b6a76c4dceb937b29bb234ef4d54581b16bd0737c8d2994a90cf4fe10a9738c7cc5b6d085c6a819f06176dab9
7a820cee0e6408f5848799011d82dd29ee7fa8c5 test, build: Separate `read_json` function into its own module (Hennadii Stepanov)
Pull request description:
Currently, 4 source files rely on the definition of the `read_json` function provided in `src/test/script_tests.cpp`.
This PR breaks this entanglement, improves code structure and maintainability.
ACKs for top commit:
fanquake:
ACK 7a820cee0e6408f5848799011d82dd29ee7fa8c5
Tree-SHA512: f1567989f76cb54ab86cc48927851a8c424b08a9483d02d4918b629e0c792108bad4ccf7fa341d57b0921d91e84bf8fa3b9c07e5fdf12c64d9d5da83e4e464fb
b0e916913cedb8154419ec818bb9094a72fc8379 clang-tidy: Force to check all headers (Hennadii Stepanov)
96ee992ac3535848e2dc717bf284339badd40dcb clang-tidy: Fix `modernize-use-default-member-init` in headers (Hennadii Stepanov)
Pull request description:
This PR:
- fixes the only [remained](https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/26705#issuecomment-1353742082) check in headers, i.e., `modernize-use-default-member-init`
- forces `clang-tidy` check all headers
Closesbitcoin/bitcoin#26703.
ACKs for top commit:
MarcoFalke:
review ACK b0e916913cedb8154419ec818bb9094a72fc8379 🍹
Tree-SHA512: 4d33fe873094914541ae81968cdb4e7a7a01b3fdd4f25bc6daa8a53f45dab80565a5b3607ddc338f122369ca5a0a2d0d09c8e78cabe1beb6bd50c115bc5c5210
dfc01ccd73e1f12698278d467c241f398da9fc7d net: simplify the call to vProcessMsg.splice() (Vasil Dimov)
Pull request description:
At the time when
```cpp
pnode->vProcessMsg.splice(pnode->vProcessMsg.end(), pnode->vRecvMsg, pnode->vRecvMsg.begin(), it);
```
is called, `it` is certainly `pnode->vRecvMsg.end()` which makes the call equivalent to:
```cpp
pnode->vProcessMsg.splice(pnode->vProcessMsg.end(), pnode->vRecvMsg, pnode->vRecvMsg.begin(), pnode->vRecvMsg.end());
```
which is equivalent to:
```cpp
pnode->vProcessMsg.splice(pnode->vProcessMsg.end(), pnode->vRecvMsg);
```
Thus, use the latter. Further, maybe irrelevant, but the latter has constant complexity while the original code is `O(length of vRecvMsg)`.
ACKs for top commit:
theStack:
Code-review ACK dfc01ccd73e1f12698278d467c241f398da9fc7d
MarcoFalke:
review ACK dfc01ccd73e1f12698278d467c241f398da9fc7d 🐑
jonatack:
Light review ACK dfc01ccd73e1f12698278d467c241f398da9fc7d
Tree-SHA512: 9f4eb61d1caf4af9a61ba2f54b915fcfe406db62c58ab1ec42f736505b6792e9379a83d0458d6cc04f289edcec070b7c962f94a920ab51701c3cab103152866f
80f39c99ef2d30e3e2d8dbc068d25cf92aa32344 addrman, refactor: combine two size functions (Amiti Uttarwar)
4885d6f197736cb89fdfac250b280ec10829d903 addrman, refactor: move count increment into Create() (Martin Zumsande)
c77c877a8e916878e09f64b2faa12eeca7528cc8 net: Load fixed seeds from reachable networks for which we don't have addresses (Martin Zumsande)
d35595a78a4a6cae72d3204c1ec3f82f77a10d56 addrman: add function to return size by network and table (Martin Zumsande)
Pull request description:
AddrMan currently doesn't track the number of its entries by network, it only knows the total number of addresses. This PR makes AddrMan keep track of these numbers, which would be helpful for multiple things:
1. Allow to specifically add fixed seeds to AddrMan of networks where we don't have any addresses yet - even if AddrMan as a whole is not empty (partly fixing #26035). This is in particular helpful if the user abruptly changes `-onlynet` settings (such that addrs that used to be reachable are no longer and vice versa), in which case they currently could get stuck and not find any outbound peers. The second commit of this PR implements this.
1. (Future work): Add logic for automatic connection management with respect to networks - such as making attempts to have at least one connection to each reachable network as suggested [here](https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/issues/26035#issuecomment-1249420209). This would involve requesting an address from a particular network from AddrMan, and expanding its corresponding function `AddrMan::Select()` to do this requires internal knowledge of the current number of addresses for each network and table to avoid getting stuck in endless loops.
1. (Future work): Perhaps display the totals to users. At least I would find this helpful to debug, the existing option (`./bitcoin-cli -addrinfo`) is rather indirect by doing the aggregation itself in each call, doesn't distinguish between new and tried, and being based on `AddrMan::GetAddr()` it's also subject to a quality filter which we probably don't want in this spot.
ACKs for top commit:
naumenkogs:
utACK 80f39c9
stratospher:
ACK 80f39c9
achow101:
ACK 80f39c99ef2d30e3e2d8dbc068d25cf92aa32344
vasild:
ACK 80f39c99ef2d30e3e2d8dbc068d25cf92aa32344
Tree-SHA512: 6359f2e3f4db7c120c0789d92d74cb7d87a2ceedb7d6a34b5eff20c7f55c5c81092d10ed94efe29afc1c66947820a0d9c14876ee0c8d1f8e068a6df4e1131927
6d58117a31a88eec3f0a103f9d1fc26cf0b48348 build: Build minisketch test in `make check`, not in `make` (Hennadii Stepanov)
Pull request description:
On master (d1e42659bbdd8da170542d8c638242cd94f71a7d):
```
$ ./autogen.sh && ./configure --without-gui --disable-wallet && make clean
$ make 2>&1 | grep LD | grep -v .la
CXXLD bitcoind
CXXLD bitcoin-cli
CXXLD bitcoin-tx
CXXLD bitcoin-util
CXXLD test/test_bitcoin
CXXLD bench/bench_bitcoin
CXXLD minisketch/test
CXXLD test/fuzz/fuzz
CXXLD univalue/test/object
CXXLD univalue/test/unitester
$ make check 2>&1 | grep LD
CCLD exhaustive_tests
CCLD tests
```
With this PR:
```
$ ./autogen.sh && ./configure --without-gui --disable-wallet && make clean
$ make 2>&1 | grep LD | grep -v .la
CXXLD bitcoind
CXXLD bitcoin-cli
CXXLD bitcoin-tx
CXXLD bitcoin-util
CXXLD test/test_bitcoin
CXXLD bench/bench_bitcoin
CXXLD test/fuzz/fuzz
CXXLD univalue/test/object
CXXLD univalue/test/unitester
$ make check 2>&1 | grep LD
CXXLD minisketch/test
CCLD exhaustive_tests
CCLD tests
```
In fact, this PR restores behavior that was before bitcoin/bitcoin#22646, and that behavior looks more optimal.
As an outcome, the `contrib/guix/libexec/build.sh` does not spend resources to build binaries which are not a part of the release package.
ACKs for top commit:
TheCharlatan:
ACK 6d58117a31a88eec3f0a103f9d1fc26cf0b48348
Tree-SHA512: 4957c8f88a01aca005813bf4c1c26f433756bf68ea0c958481c638ead229fa8e23ecae3a8ac31ea555876ba6f2cc10ecd91caf2e2f664de5cb529ec05fb38fa7
a24e633339c45eaca28fc7af0488956332ac300c refactor: rpc: set TxToJSON default verbosity to SHOW_DETAILS (stickies-v)
Pull request description:
`TxToJSON()` and `TxToUniv()` are only to be called when we want to decode the transaction (i.e. its details) into JSON. If `TxVerbosity` is `SHOW_TXID`, the function should not have been (and currently is not) called in the first place.
There is no behaviour change, current logic simply assumes anything less than `TxVerbosity::SHOW_DETAILS_AND_PREVOUT` equals `TxVerbosity::SHOW_DETAILS`. With this change, the assumptions and intent become more explicit.
ACKs for top commit:
w0xlt:
ACK a24e633339
Tree-SHA512: b97235adae49b972bdbe10aca1438643fb35ec66a4e57166b1975b3015bc5a06a711feebe4453a8fefe71781e484b21ef80847d8e8a33694a3abcc863accd4d7
The previous behavior, skipping some L3 DisconnectBlock calls,
but still attempting to reconnect these blocks at L4, makes
ConnectBlock assert.
The variable skipped_l3_checks is introduced because even with an
insufficient cache for the L3 checks, the L1/L2 checks in the same
loop should still be completed.
Fixes#25563.
