Addnode (manual) peers connected to us via the cjdns network are currently not
detected by CConnman::GetAddedNodeInfo(), i.e. fConnected is always false.
This causes the following issues:
- RPC `getaddednodeinfo` incorrectly shows them as not connected
- CConnman::ThreadOpenAddedConnections() continually retries to connect them
fa09451f8e6799682d7e7c863f25334fd1c7dce3 Add lint check for bitcoin-config.h include IWYU pragma (MarcoFalke)
dddd40ba8267dea11a3eb03d5cf8b51dbb99be5d scripted-diff: Add IWYU pragma keep to bitcoin-config.h includes (MarcoFalke)
Pull request description:
The `bitcoin-config.h` includes have issues:
* The header is incompatible with iwyu, because symbols may be defined or not defined. So the `IWYU pragma: keep` is needed to keep the include when a symbol is not defined on a platform. Compare the previous discussion in https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/29408#issuecomment-1948959711
* Guarding the includes by `HAVE_CONFIG_H` is verbose and brittle. Now that all build config dependencies have been removed from low level headers, the benefits are questionable, and the guard can be removed. The linter could also be tricked by guarding the include by `#if defined(HAVE_C0NFIG_H)` (`O` replaced by `0`). Compare the previous discussion in https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/29404#discussion_r1483189853 .
ACKs for top commit:
achow101:
ACK fa09451f8e6799682d7e7c863f25334fd1c7dce3
TheCharlatan:
ACK fa09451f8e6799682d7e7c863f25334fd1c7dce3
hebasto:
re-ACK fa09451f8e6799682d7e7c863f25334fd1c7dce3, only rebased since my recent [review](https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/29494#pullrequestreview-2028864535) (`timedata.cpp` removed in https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/29623).
Tree-SHA512: 47cb973f7f24bc625acc4e78683371863675d186780236d55d886cf4130e05a78bb04f1d731aae7088313b8e963a9677cc77cf518187dbd99d776f6421ca9b52
a68fed111be393ddbbcd7451f78bc63601253ee0 net: Fix misleading comment for Discover (laanwj)
7766dd280d9a4a7ffdfcec58224d0985cfd4169b net: Replace ifname check with IFF_LOOPBACK in Discover (laanwj)
Pull request description:
Checking the interface name is kind of brittle. In the age of network namespaces and containers, there is no reason a loopback interface can't be called differently.
Check for the `IFF_LOOPBACK` flag to detect loopback interface instead.
Also remove a misleading comment in Discover's doc comment.
ACKs for top commit:
sipa:
utACK a68fed111be393ddbbcd7451f78bc63601253ee0
willcl-ark:
utACK a68fed111be393ddbbcd7451f78bc63601253ee0
theuni:
utACK a68fed111be393ddbbcd7451f78bc63601253ee0. Satoshi-era brittleness :)
Tree-SHA512: e2d7fc541f40f6a6af08286e7bcb0873ff55debdcd8b38b03f274897b673a6fb51d84d6c7241a02a9567ddf2645f50231d91bb1f55307ba7c6e68196c29b0edf
82f41d76f1c6ad38290917dad5499ffbe6b3974d Added seednode prioritization message to help output (tdb3)
3120a4678ab2a71a381e847688f44068749cfa97 Gives seednode priority over dnsseed if both are provided (Sergi Delgado Segura)
Pull request description:
This is a follow-up of #27577
If both `seednode` and `dnsseed` are provided, the node will start a race between them in order to fetch data to feed the `addrman`.
This PR gives priority to `seednode` over `dnsseed` so if some nodes are provided as seeds, they can be tried before defaulting to the `dnsseeds`
ACKs for top commit:
davidgumberg:
untested reACK 82f41d76f1
itornaza:
tested re-ACK 82f41d76f1c6ad38290917dad5499ffbe6b3974d
achow101:
ACK 82f41d76f1c6ad38290917dad5499ffbe6b3974d
cbergqvist:
ACK 82f41d76f1c6ad38290917dad5499ffbe6b3974d
Tree-SHA512: 4e39e10a7449af6cd9b8f9f6878f846b94bca11baf89ff2d4fbcd4f28293978a6ed71a3a86cea36d49eca891314c834e32af93f37a09c2cc698a878f84d31c62
c6be144c4b774a03a8bcab5a165768cf81e9b06b Remove timedata (stickies-v)
92e72b5d0d49aa395e626c238bc28aba8e4c3d44 [net processing] Move IgnoresIncomingTxs to PeerManagerInfo (dergoegge)
7d9c3ec622d73a98d07ab3cee78751718982a5bc [net processing] Introduce PeerManagerInfo (dergoegge)
ee178dfcc1175e0af8163216c9c024f4bfc97965 Add TimeOffsets helper class (stickies-v)
55361a15d1aa6984051441bce88112000688fb43 [net processing] Use std::chrono for type-safe time offsets (stickies-v)
038fd979effb54ee76ce1b7cf078e920c652326a [net processing] Move nTimeOffset to net_processing (dergoegge)
Pull request description:
[An earlier approach](1d226ae1f9/) in #28956 involved simplifying and refactoring the network-adjusted time calculation logic, but this was eventually [left out](https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/28956#issuecomment-1904214370) of the PR to make it easier for reviewers to focus on consensus logic changes.
Since network-adjusted time is now only used for warning/informational purposes, cleaning up the logic (building on @dergoegge's approach in #28956) should be quite straightforward and uncontroversial. The main changes are:
- Previously, we would only calculate the time offset from the first 199 outbound peers that we connected to. This limitation is now removed, and we have a proper rolling calculation. I've reduced the set to 50 outbound peers, which seems plenty.
- Previously, we would automatically use the network-adjusted time if the difference was < 70 mins, and warn the user if the difference was larger than that. Since there is no longer any automated time adjustment, I've changed the warning threshold to ~~20~~ 10 minutes (which is an arbitrary number).
- Previously, a warning would only be raised once, and then never again until node restart. This behaviour is now updated to 1) warn to log for every new outbound peer for as long as we appear out of sync, 2) have the RPC warning toggled on/off whenever we go in/out of sync, and 3) have the GUI warn whenever we are out of sync (again), but limited to 1 messagebox per 60 minutes
- no more globals
- remove the `-maxtimeadjustment` startup arg
Closes#4521
ACKs for top commit:
sr-gi:
Re-ACK [c6be144](c6be144c4b)
achow101:
reACK c6be144c4b774a03a8bcab5a165768cf81e9b06b
dergoegge:
utACK c6be144c4b774a03a8bcab5a165768cf81e9b06b
Tree-SHA512: 1063d639542e882186cdcea67d225ad1f97847f44253621a8c4b36c4d777e8f5cb0efe86bc279f01e819d33056ae4364c3300cc7400c087fb16c3f39b3e16b96
Checking the interface name is kind of brittle. In the age of network
namespaces and containers, there is no reason a loopback interface can't
be called differently.
Check for the `IFF_LOOPBACK` flag to detect loopback interface instead.
fd81a37239541d0d508402cd4eeb28f38128c1f2 net: attempts to connect to all resolved addresses when connecting to a node (Sergi Delgado Segura)
Pull request description:
This is a follow-up of #28155 motivated by https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/28155#discussion_r1362677038
## Rationale
Prior to this, when establishing a network connection via `CConnman::ConnectNode`, if the connection needed address resolution, a single address would be picked at random from the resolved addresses and our node would try to connect to it. However, this would lead to the behavior of `ConnectNode` being unpredictable when the address was resolved to various ips (e.g. the address resolving to IPv4 and IPv6, but we only support one of them).
This patches the aforementioned behavior by going over all resolved IPs until a valid one is found or until we
exhaust them.
ACKs for top commit:
mzumsande:
re-ACK fd81a37239541d0d508402cd4eeb28f38128c1f2 (just looked at diff, only small logging change)
achow101:
ACK fd81a37239541d0d508402cd4eeb28f38128c1f2
vasild:
ACK fd81a37239541d0d508402cd4eeb28f38128c1f2
Tree-SHA512: fa1ebc5c84fe61dd0a7fe1113ae2d594a75ad661c43ed8984a31fc9bc50f166b2759b0d8d84ee5dc247691eff78c8156fac970af797bbcbf67492eec0353fb58
Prior to this, when establishing a network connection via CConnman::ConnectNode,
if the connection needed address resolution, a single address would be picked
at random from the resolved addresses and our node will try to connect to it. However,
this would lead to the behavior of ConnectNode being unpredictable when the address
was resolved to various ips (e.g. the address resolving to IPv4 and IPv6, but we only
support one of them).
This patches the aforementioned behavior by going over all resolved IPs until we find one
we can connect to or until we exhaust them.
Limit number of IPs learned from a single DNS seed to 32, to prevent the results from
one DNS seed from dominating AddrMan. Note that the number of results from a UDP DNS query is
bounded to 33 already, but it is possible for it to use TCP where a potentially enormous
number of results can be returned.
Closes#16070.
567cec9a05e1261e955535f734826b12341684b6 doc: add release notes and help text for unix sockets (Matthew Zipkin)
bfe51928911daf484ae07deb52a7ff0bcb2526ae test: cover UNIX sockets in feature_proxy.py (Matthew Zipkin)
c65c0d01630b44fa71321ea7ad68d5f9fbb7aefb init: allow UNIX socket path for -proxy and -onion (Matthew Zipkin)
c3bd43142eba77dcf1acd4984e437759f65e237a gui: accomodate unix socket Proxy in updateDefaultProxyNets() (Matthew Zipkin)
a88bf9dedd1d8c1db0a9c8b663dab3e3c2f0f030 i2p: construct Session with Proxy instead of CService (Matthew Zipkin)
d9318a37ec09fe0b002815a7e48710e530620ae2 net: split ConnectToSocket() from ConnectDirectly() for unix sockets (Matthew Zipkin)
ac2ecf3182fb5ad9bcd41540b19382376114d6ee proxy: rename randomize_credentials to m_randomize_credentials (Matthew Zipkin)
a89c3f59dc44eaf4f59912c1accfc0ce5d61933a netbase: extend Proxy class to wrap UNIX socket as well as TCP (Matthew Zipkin)
3a7d6548effa6cd9a4a5413b690c2fd85da4ef65 net: move CreateSock() calls from ConnectNode() to netbase methods (Matthew Zipkin)
74f568cb6fd5c74b7b9bf0ce69876430746a53b1 netbase: allow CreateSock() to create UNIX sockets if supported (Matthew Zipkin)
bae86c8d318d06818aa75a9ebe3db864197f0bc6 netbase: refactor CreateSock() to accept sa_family_t (Matthew Zipkin)
adb3a3e51de205cc69b1a58647c65c04fa6c6362 configure: test for unix domain sockets (Matthew Zipkin)
Pull request description:
Closes https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/issues/27252
UNIX domain sockets are a mechanism for inter-process communication that are faster than local TCP ports (because there is no need for TCP overhead) and potentially more secure because access is managed by the filesystem instead of serving an open port on the system.
There has been work on [unix domain sockets before](https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/9979) but for now I just wanted to start on this single use-case which is enabling unix sockets from the client side, specifically connecting to a local Tor proxy (Tor can listen on unix sockets and even enforces strict curent-user-only access permission before binding) configured by `-onion=` or `-proxy=`
I copied the prefix `unix:` usage from Tor. With this patch built locally you can test with your own filesystem path (example):
`tor --SocksPort unix:/Users/matthewzipkin/torsocket/x`
`bitcoind -proxy=unix:/Users/matthewzipkin/torsocket/x`
Prep work for this feature includes:
- Moving where and how we create `sockaddr` and `Sock` to accommodate `AF_UNIX` without disturbing `CService`
- Expanding `Proxy` class to represent either a `CService` or a UNIX socket (by its file path)
Future work:
- Enable UNIX sockets for ZMQ (https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/27679)
- Enable UNIX sockets for I2P SAM proxy (some code is included in this PR but not tested or exposed to user options yet)
- Enable UNIX sockets on windows where supported
- Update Network Proxies dialog in GUI to support UNIX sockets
ACKs for top commit:
Sjors:
re-ACK 567cec9a05e1261e955535f734826b12341684b6
tdb3:
re ACK for 567cec9a05e1261e955535f734826b12341684b6.
achow101:
ACK 567cec9a05e1261e955535f734826b12341684b6
vasild:
ACK 567cec9a05e1261e955535f734826b12341684b6
Tree-SHA512: de81860e56d5de83217a18df4c35297732b4ad491e293a0153d2d02a0bde1d022700a1131279b187ef219651487537354b9d06d10fde56225500c7e257df92c1
0a533613fb44207053796fd01a9f4b523a3153d4 docs: add release notes for #27114 (brunoerg)
e6b8f19de9a6d1c477d0bbda18d17794cd81a6f4 test: add coverage for whitelisting manual connections (brunoerg)
c985eb854cc86deb747caea5283c17cf51b6a983 test: add option to speed up tx relay/mempool sync (brunoerg)
66bc6e2d1749f43d7b314aa2784a06af78440170 Accept "in" and "out" flags to -whitelist to allow whitelisting manual connections (Luke Dashjr)
8e06be347c5e14cbe75256eba170e0867f95f360 net_processing: Move extra service flag into InitializeNode (Luke Dashjr)
9133fd69a5cc9a0ab1a06a60d09f1b7e1039018e net: Move `NetPermissionFlags::Implicit` verification to `AddWhitelistPermissionFlags` (Luke Dashjr)
2863d7dddb62d987b3e1c3b8bfad7083f0f774b2 net: store `-whitelist{force}relay` values in `CConnman` (brunoerg)
Pull request description:
Revives #17167. It allows whitelisting manual connections. Fixes#9923
Since there are some PRs/issues around this topic, I'll list some motivations/comments for whitelisting outbound connections from them:
- Speed-up tx relay/mempool sync for testing purposes (my personal motivation for this) - In #26970, theStack pointed out that we whitelist peers to speed up tx relay for fast mempool synchronization, however, since it applies only for inbound connections and considering the topology `node0 <--- node1 <---- node2 <--- ... <-- nodeN`, if a tx is submitted from any node other than node0, the mempool synchronization can take quite long.
- https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/29058#issuecomment-1865155764 - "Before enabling -v2transport by default (which I'd image may happen after https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/24748) we could consider a way to force manual connections to be only-v1 or even only-v2 (disabling reconnect-with-v1). A possibility could be through a net permission flag, if https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/27114 makes it in."
- https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/17167#issuecomment-1168606032 - "This would allow us to use https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/25355 when making outgoing connections to all nodes, except to whitelisted ones for which we would use our persistent I2P address."
- Force-relay/mempool permissions for a node you intentionally connected to.
ACKs for top commit:
achow101:
ACK 0a533613fb44207053796fd01a9f4b523a3153d4
sr-gi:
re-ACK [0a53361](0a533613fb)
pinheadmz:
ACK 0a533613fb44207053796fd01a9f4b523a3153d4
Tree-SHA512: 97a79bb854110da04540897d2619eda409d829016aafdf1825ab5515334b0b42ef82f33cd41587af235b3af6ddcec3f2905ca038b5ab22e4c8a03d34f27aebe1
fa391513949b7a3b56321436e2015c7e9e6dac2b refactor: Remove unused error() (MarcoFalke)
fad0335517096f435d76adce7833e213d3cc23d1 scripted-diff: Replace error() with LogError() (MarcoFalke)
fa808fb74972637840675e310f6d4a0f06028d61 refactor: Make error() return type void (MarcoFalke)
fa1d62434843866d242bff9f9c55cb838a4f0d83 scripted-diff: return error(...); ==> error(...); return false; (MarcoFalke)
fa9a5e80ab86c997102a1c3d4ba017bbe86641d5 refactor: Add missing {} around error() calls (MarcoFalke)
Pull request description:
`error(...)` has many issues:
* It is often used in the context of `return error(...)`, implying that it has a "fancy" type, creating confusion with `util::Result/Error`
* `-logsourcelocations` does not work with it, because it will pretend the error happened inside of `logging.h`
* The log line contains `ERROR: `, as opposed to `[error]`, like for other errors logged with `LogError`.
Fix all issues by removing it.
ACKs for top commit:
fjahr:
re-utACK fa391513949b7a3b56321436e2015c7e9e6dac2b
stickies-v:
re-ACK fa391513949b7a3b56321436e2015c7e9e6dac2b, no changes since 4a903741b0
ryanofsky:
Code review ACK fa391513949b7a3b56321436e2015c7e9e6dac2b. Just rebase since last review
Tree-SHA512: ec5bb502ab0d3733fdb14a8a00762638fce0417afd8dd6294ae0d485ce2b7ca5b1efeb50fc2cd7467f6c652e4ed3e99b0f283b08aeca04bbfb7ea4f2c95d283a
2cc8ca19f4185490f30a49516c890b2289fbab71 [test] Use deterministic addrman in addrman info tests (stratospher)
a8978661093500df8d8dcf2a9c90837afacd0aab [test] Restart a node with empty addrman (stratospher)
71c19915c0c716d6f8a539dd92b8ad41e8c447ee [test] Use deterministic addrman in addpeeraddress test (stratospher)
7b868e6b678502e86571976d696c0e3cb72c0884 Revert "test: avoid non-determinism in asmap-addrman test" (stratospher)
69e091f3e1f65b12cf1804e7d39651f55a01827a [init] Create deterministic addrman in tests using -test=addrman (stratospher)
be25ac3092b7755e26e1ec6c33a27cd0e3dd9eac [init] Remove -addrmantest command line arg (stratospher)
802e6e128bba5ffa6d4ec53ff45acccb7cb28f21 [init] Add new command line arg for use only in functional tests (stratospher)
Pull request description:
An address is placed in a `[bucket,position]` in the addrman table (new table or tried table) using the `addpeeraddress` RPC. This `[bucket,position]` is calculated using `nKey`(and other metrics) for the addrman which is chosen randomly during every run.
Supposing there are 2 addresses to be placed in an addrman table. During every test run, a different `[bucket,position]` would be calculated for each address.These calculated `[bucket,position]` could even be the same for the 2 addresses in some test runs and result in collisions in the addrman. We wouldn't be able to predict when the collisions are going to happen because we can't predict the `nKey` value which is chosen at random. This can cause flaky tests.
Because of these non deterministic collisions, we are limited in what we can do to test addrman functionality. Currently in our tests don't add a second address to prevent these collisions from happening - we only keep 1 address in the new table and 1 address in the tried table. See https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/26988#discussion_r1091145647, https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/23084, [#22831(comment)](https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/22831/files#r708302639).
This PR lets us create a deterministic addrman with fixed `nKey` so that we can know the `[bucket,position]` collisions beforehand, safely add more addresses in an addrman table and write more extensive tests.
ACKs for top commit:
amitiuttarwar:
ACK 2cc8ca19f4185490f30a49516c890b2289fbab71
achow101:
ACK 2cc8ca19f4185490f30a49516c890b2289fbab71
0xB10C:
ACK 2cc8ca19f4185490f30a49516c890b2289fbab71
mzumsande:
Code Review ACK 2cc8ca19f4185490f30a49516c890b2289fbab71
Tree-SHA512: 8acd9bdfe7de1eb44d22373bf13533d8ecf602df966fdd5b8b78afcd8cc35a286c95d2712f67a89473a0d68dded7d38f5599f6e4bf95a6589475444545bfb189
This fixes the log output when -logsourcelocations is used.
Also, instead of 'ERROR:', the log will now say '[error]', like other
errors logged with LogError.
-BEGIN VERIFY SCRIPT-
sed -i --regexp-extended 's! error\("([^"]+)"! LogError("\1\\n"!g' $( git grep -l ' error(' ./src/ )
-END VERIFY SCRIPT-
27f260aa6e04f82dad78e9a06d58927546143a27 net: remove now unused global 'g_initial_block_download_completed' (furszy)
aff7d92b1500e2478ce36a7e86ae47df47dda178 test: add coverage for peerman adaptive connections service flags (furszy)
6ed53602ac7c565273b5722de167cb2569a0e381 net: peer manager, dynamically adjust desirable services flag (furszy)
9f36e591c551ec2e58a6496334541bfdae8fdfe5 net: move state dependent peer services flags (furszy)
f9ac96b8d6f4eba23c88f302b22a2c676e351263 net: decouple state independent service flags from desirable ones (furszy)
97df4e38879d2644aeec34c1eef241fed627333e net: store best block tip time inside PeerManager (furszy)
Pull request description:
Derived from #28120 discussion.
By relocating the peer desirable services flags into the peer manager, we
allow the connections acceptance process to handle post-IBD potential
stalling scenarios.
The peer manager will be able to dynamically adjust the services flags
based on the node's proximity to the tip (back and forth). Allowing the node
to recover from the following post-IBD scenario:
Suppose the node has successfully synced the chain, but later experienced
dropped connections and remained inactive for a duration longer than the limited
peers threshold (the timeframe within which limited peers can provide blocks). In
such cases, upon reconnecting to the network, the node might only establish
connections with limited peers, filling up all available outbound slots. Resulting
in an inability to synchronize the chain (because limited peers will not provide
blocks older than the `NODE_NETWORK_LIMITED_MIN_BLOCKS` threshold).
ACKs for top commit:
achow101:
ACK 27f260aa6e04f82dad78e9a06d58927546143a27
vasild:
ACK 27f260aa6e04f82dad78e9a06d58927546143a27
naumenkogs:
ACK 27f260aa6e04f82dad78e9a06d58927546143a27
mzumsande:
Light Code Review ACK 27f260aa6e04f82dad78e9a06d58927546143a27
andrewtoth:
ACK 27f260aa6e04f82dad78e9a06d58927546143a27
Tree-SHA512: 07befb9bcd0b60a4e7c45e4429c02e7b6c66244f0910f4b2ad97c9b98258b6f46c914660a717b5ed4ef4814d0dbfae6e18e6559fe9bec7d0fbc2034109200953
bc9283c4415a932ec1eeb70ca2aa4399c80437b3 [test] Add functional test to test early key response behaviour in BIP 324 (stratospher)
ffe6a56d75c0b47d0729e4e0b7225a827b43ad89 [test] Check whether v2 TestNode performs downgrading (stratospher)
ba737358a37438c18f0fba723eab10ccfd9aae9b [test] Add functional tests to test v2 P2P behaviour (stratospher)
4115cf995647d1a513caecb54a4ff3f51927aa8e [test] Ignore BIP324 decoy messages (stratospher)
8c054aa04d33b247744b3747cd5bf3005a013e90 [test] Allow inbound and outbound connections supporting v2 P2P protocol (stratospher)
382894c3acd2dbf3e4198814f547c75b6fb17706 [test] Reconnect using v1 P2P when v2 P2P terminates due to magic byte mismatch (stratospher)
a94e350ac0e5b65ef23a84b05fb10d1204c98c97 [test] Build v2 P2P messages (stratospher)
bb7bffed799dc5ad8b606768164fce46d4cbf9d0 [test] Use lock for sending P2P messages in test framework (stratospher)
5b91fb14aba7d7fe45c9ac364526815bec742356 [test] Read v2 P2P messages (stratospher)
05bddb20f5cc9036fd680500bde8ece70dbf0646 [test] Perform initial v2 handshake (stratospher)
a049d1bd08c8cdb3b693520f24f8a82572dcaab1 [test] Introduce EncryptedP2PState object in P2PConnection (stratospher)
b89fa59e715a185d9fa7fce089dad4273d3b1532 [test] Construct class to handle v2 P2P protocol functions (stratospher)
8d6c848a48530893ca40be5c1285541b3e7a94f3 [test] Move MAGIC_BYTES to messages.py (stratospher)
595ad4b16880ae1f23463ca9985381c8eae945d8 [test/crypto] Add ECDH (stratospher)
4487b8051797173c7ab432e75efa370afb03b529 [rpc/net] Allow v2 p2p support in addconnection (stratospher)
Pull request description:
This PR introduces support for v2 P2P encryption(BIP 324) in the existing functional test framework and adds functional tests for the same.
### commits overview
1. introduces a new class `EncryptedP2PState` to store the keys, functions for performing the initial v2 handshake and encryption/decryption.
3. this class is used by `P2PConnection` in inbound/outbound connections to perform the initial v2 handshake before the v1 version handshake. Only after the initial v2 handshake is performed do application layer P2P messages(version, verack etc..) get exchanged. (in a v2 connection)
- `v2_state` is the object of class `EncryptedP2PState` in `P2PConnection` used to store its keys, session-id etc.
- a node [advertising](https://github.com/stratospher/blogosphere/blob/main/integration_test_bip324.md#advertising-to-support-v2-p2p) support for v2 P2P is different from a node actually [supporting v2 P2P](https://github.com/stratospher/blogosphere/blob/main/integration_test_bip324.md#supporting-v2-p2p) (differ when false advertisement of services occur)
- introduce a boolean variable `supports_v2_p2p` in `P2PConnection` to denote if it supports v2 P2P.
- introduce a boolean variable `advertises_v2_p2p` to denote whether `P2PConnection` which mimics peer behaviour advertises V2 P2P support. Default option is `False`.
- In the test framework, you can create Inbound and Outbound connections to `TestNode`
1. During **Inbound Connections**, `P2PConnection` is the initiator [`TestNode` <--------- `P2PConnection`]
- Case 1:
- if the `TestNode` advertises/signals v2 P2P support (means `self.nodes[i]` set up with `"-v2transport=1"`), different behaviour will be exhibited based on whether:
1. `P2PConnection` supports v2 P2P
2. `P2PConnection` does not support v2 P2P
- In a real world scenario, the initiator node would intrinsically know if they support v2 P2P based on whatever code they choose to run. However, in the test scenario where we mimic peer behaviour, we have no way of knowing if `P2PConnection` should support v2 P2P or not. So `supports_v2_p2p` boolean variable is used as an option to enable support for v2 P2P in `P2PConnection`.
- Since the `TestNode` advertises v2 P2P support (using "-v2transport=1"), our initiator `P2PConnection` would send:
1. (if the `P2PConnection` supports v2 P2P) ellswift + garbage bytes to initiate the connection
2. (if the `P2PConnection` does not support v2 P2P) version message to initiate the connection
- Case 2:
- if the `TestNode` doesn't signal v2 P2P support; `P2PConnection` being the initiator would send version message to initiate a connection.
2. During **Outbound Connections** [TestNode --------> P2PConnection]
- initiator `TestNode` would send:
- (if the `P2PConnection` advertises v2 P2P) ellswift + garbage bytes to initiate the connection
- (if the `P2PConnection` advertises v2 P2P) version message to initiate the connection
- Suppose `P2PConnection` advertises v2 P2P support when it actually doesn't support v2 P2P (false advertisement scenario)
- `TestNode` sends ellswift + garbage bytes
- `P2PConnection` receives but can't process it and disconnects.
- `TestNode` then tries using v1 P2P and sends version message
- `P2PConnection` receives/processes this successfully and they communicate on v1 P2P
4. the encrypted P2P messages follow a different format - 3 byte length + 1-13 byte message_type + payload + 16 byte MAC
5. includes support for testing decoy messages and v2 connection downgrade(using false advertisement - when a v2 node makes an outbound connection to a node which doesn't support v2 but is advertised as v2 by some malicious
intermediary)
### run the tests
* functional test - `test/functional/p2p_v2_encrypted.py` `test/functional/p2p_v2_earlykeyresponse.py`
I'm also super grateful to @ dhruv for his really valuable feedback on this branch.
Also written a more elaborate explanation here - https://github.com/stratospher/blogosphere/blob/main/integration_test_bip324.md
ACKs for top commit:
naumenkogs:
ACK bc9283c4415a932ec1eeb70ca2aa4399c80437b3
mzumsande:
Code Review ACK bc9283c4415a932ec1eeb70ca2aa4399c80437b3
theStack:
Code-review ACK bc9283c4415a932ec1eeb70ca2aa4399c80437b3
glozow:
ACK bc9283c4415a932ec1eeb70ca2aa4399c80437b3
Tree-SHA512: 9b54ed27e925e1775e0e0d35e959cdbf2a9a1aab7bcf5d027e66f8b59780bdd0458a7a4311ddc7dd67657a4a2a2cd5034ead75524420d58a83f642a8304c9811
This test-only RPC is required when a TestNode initiates
an outbound v2 p2p connection. Add a new arg `v2transport`
so that the node can attempt v2 connections.
No behavior change. Just an intermediate refactoring.
By relocating the peer desirable services flags into the peer
manager, we allow the connections acceptance process to handle
post-IBD potential stalling scenarios.
In the follow-up commit(s), the desirable service flags will be
dynamically adjusted to detect post-IBD stalling scenarios (such
as a +48-hour inactive node that must prefer full node connections
instead of limited peer connections because they cannot provide
historical blocks). Additionally, this encapsulation enable us
to customize the connections decision-making process based on
new user's configurations in the future.
fb5bfed26a564014b83ccfc96ff00b630930fc61 cli: add transport protcol column to -netinfo (Martin Zumsande)
9eed22e870e650cadf5f65650917da21836d2bb0 net: attempt v2 transport for addrfetch connections if we support it (Martin Zumsande)
770c0311ef5e35444efe4fd26f7bb5782624cf2c net: attempt v2 transport for manual connections if we support it (Martin Zumsande)
Pull request description:
Some preparations before enabling `-v2transport` as the default:
* Use v2 for `-connect`, `-addnode` config arg and `-seednode` if `-v2transport` is enabled.
Our peer may or may not support v2, but I don't think an extra option is necessary for any of these (we have that for the `addnode` rpc), because we have the reconnection mechanism that will try again with `v1` if our peer doesn't support `v2`.
* Add a column for the transport protocol to `-netinfo`. I added it next to the `net` column because I thought it looked nice there, but if people prefer it somewhere else I'm happy to move it.
ACKs for top commit:
sipa:
utACK fb5bfed26a564014b83ccfc96ff00b630930fc61
achow101:
ACK fb5bfed26a564014b83ccfc96ff00b630930fc61
stratospher:
tested ACK fb5bfed. addrfetch + manual connections aren't frequent and it would be useful to have this for transition to v2 one day.
theStack:
ACK fb5bfed26a564014b83ccfc96ff00b630930fc61
kristapsk:
ACK fb5bfed26a564014b83ccfc96ff00b630930fc61
Tree-SHA512: c4575ad11b99613870b342acae369fa08f877ac79e6e04eb62e94ad7a92d528e289183c0963c78aa779ba11cb91e2a6fad7c8b0d813126c46c3e5b54bd962c26
-addrmantest is only used in `p2p_node_network_limited.py` test to
test if the node self-advertises a hard-coded local address
(which wouldn't be advertised in the tests because it's unroutable
without the test-only code path) to check pruning-related services
are correct in that addr.
Remove -addrmantest because the self advertisement happens because
of hard coded test path logic, and expected services are nominal
due to how easily the test-only code could diverge from mainnet
logic. It's also being used only in 1 test.
This affects manual connections made either with -connect, or with
-addnode provided as a bitcoind config arg (the addnode RPC has an
extra option for v2).
We don't necessarily know if our peer supports v2, but will reconnect
with v1 if they don't. In order to do that, improve the reconnection
behavior such that we will reconnect after a sleep of 500ms
(which usually should be enough for our peer to send us their
version message).
Making the `GenerateRandomKey` helper available to other modules via
key.{h.cpp} allows us to create random private keys directly at
instantiation of CKey, in contrast to the two-step process of creating
the instance and then having to call `MakeNewKey(...)`.
3ea54e5db7d53da5afa321e1800c29aa269dd3b3 net: Add continuous ASMap health check logging (Fabian Jahr)
28d7e55dff826a69f3f8e58139dbffb611cc5947 test: Add tests for unfiltered GetAddr usage (Fabian Jahr)
b8843d37aed1276ff8527328c956c70c6e02ee13 fuzz: Let fuzzers use filter options in GetAddr/GetAddresses (Fabian Jahr)
e16f420547fc72a5a2902927aa7138e43c0fb7c8 net: Optionally include terrible addresses in GetAddr results (Fabian Jahr)
Pull request description:
There are certain statistics we can collect by running all our known clearnet addresses against the ASMap file. This could show issues with a maliciously manipulated file or with an old file that has decayed with time.
This is just a proof of concept for now. My idea currently is to run the analysis once per day and print the results to logs if an ASMap file is used.
ACKs for top commit:
achow101:
ACK 3ea54e5db7d53da5afa321e1800c29aa269dd3b3
mzumsande:
ACK 3ea54e5db7d53da5afa321e1800c29aa269dd3b3
brunoerg:
crACK 3ea54e5db7d53da5afa321e1800c29aa269dd3b3
Tree-SHA512: 777acbfac43cc43ce4a0a3612434e4ddbc65f59ae8ffc9e24f21de09011bccb297f0599cbaa82bcf40ef68e5af582c4e98556379db7ceff7d9f97574a1cf8e09
fa79a881ce0537e1d74da296a7513730438d2a02 refactor: P2P transport without serialize version and type (MarcoFalke)
fa9b5f4fe32c0cfe2e477bb11912756f84a52cfe refactor: NetMsg::Make() without nVersion (MarcoFalke)
66669da4a5ca9edf2a40d20879d9a8aaf2b9e2ee Remove unused Make() overload in netmessagemaker.h (MarcoFalke)
fa0ed0794161d937d2d3385963c1aa5624b60d17 refactor: VectorWriter without nVersion (MarcoFalke)
Pull request description:
Now that the serialize framework ignores the serialize version and serialize type, everything related to it can be removed from the code.
This is the first step, removing dead code from the P2P stack. A different pull will remove it from the wallet and other parts.
ACKs for top commit:
ajtowns:
reACK fa79a881ce0537e1d74da296a7513730438d2a02
Tree-SHA512: 785b413580d980f51f0d4f70ea5e0a99ce14cd12cb065393de2f5254891be94a14f4266110c8b87bd2dbc37467676655bce13bdb295ab139749fcd8b61bd5110
to allocate our limited outbound slots correctly, and to ensure addnode
connections benefit from their intended protections.
Our addnode logic usually connects the addnode peers before the automatic
outbound logic does, but not always, as a connection race can occur. If an
addnode peer disconnects us and if it was the only one from its network, there
can be a race between reconnecting to it with the addnode thread, and it being
picked as automatic network-specific outbound peer. Or our internet connection
or router, or the addnode peer, could be temporarily offline, and then return
online during the automatic outbound thread. Or we could add a new manual peer
using the addnode RPC at that time.
The race can be more apparent when our node doesn't know many peers, or with
networks like cjdns that currently have few bitcoin peers.
When an addnode peer is connected as an automatic outbound peer and is the only
connection we have to a network, it can be protected by our new outbound
eviction logic and persist in the "wrong role".
Examples on mainnet using logging added in the same pull request:
2023-08-12T14:51:05.681743Z [opencon] [net.cpp:1949] [ThreadOpenConnections]
[net:debug] Not making automatic network-specific outbound-full-relay connection
to i2p peer selected for manual (addnode) connection: [geh...odq.b32.i2p]:0
2023-08-13T03:59:28.050853Z [opencon] [net.cpp:1949] [ThreadOpenConnections]
[net:debug] Not making automatic block-relay-only connection to onion peer
selected for manual (addnode) connection: kpg...aid.onion:8333
2023-08-13T16:21:26.979052Z [opencon] [net.cpp:1949] [ThreadOpenConnections]
[net:debug] Not making automatic network-specific outbound-full-relay connection
to cjdns peer selected for manual (addnode) connection: [fcc...8ce]:8333
2023-08-14T20:43:53.401271Z [opencon] [net.cpp:1949] [ThreadOpenConnections]
[net:debug] Not making automatic network-specific outbound-full-relay connection
to cjdns peer selected for manual (addnode) connection: [fc7...59e]:8333
2023-08-15T00:10:01.894147Z [opencon] [net.cpp:1949] [ThreadOpenConnections]
[net:debug] Not making automatic feeler connection to i2p peer selected for
manual (addnode) connection: geh...odq.b32.i2p:8333
Finally, there does not seem to be a reason to make block-relay or short-lived
feeler connections to addnode peers, as the addnode logic will ensure we connect
to them if they are up, within the addnode connection limit.
Fix these issues by checking if the address is an addnode peer in our automatic
outbound connection logic.
0420f99f429ce2382057e101859067f40de47be0 Create net_peer_connection unit tests (Jon Atack)
4b834f649921aceb44d3e0b5a2ffd7847903f9f7 Allow unit tests to access additional CConnman members (Jon Atack)
34b9ef443bc2655a85c8802edc5d5d48d792a286 net/rpc: Makes CConnman::GetAddedNodeInfo able to return only non-connected address on request (Sergi Delgado Segura)
94e8882d820969ddc83f24f4cbe1515a886da4ea rpc: Prevents adding the same ip more than once when formatted differently (Sergi Delgado Segura)
2574b7e177ef045e64f1dd48cb000640ff5103d3 net/rpc: Check all resolved addresses in ConnectNode rather than just one (Sergi Delgado Segura)
Pull request description:
## Rationale
Currently, `addnode` has a couple of corner cases that allow it to either connect to the same peer more than once, hence wasting outbound connection slots, or add redundant information to `m_added_nodes`, hence making Bitcoin iterate through useless data on a regular basis.
### Connecting to the same node more than once
In general, connecting to the same node more than once is something we should try to prevent. Currently, this is possible via `addnode` in two different ways:
1. Calling `addnode` more than once in a short time period, using two equivalent but distinct addresses
2. Calling `addnode add` using an IP, and `addnode onetry` after with an address that resolved to the same IP
For the former, the issue boils down to `CConnman::ThreadOpenAddedConnections` calling `CConnman::GetAddedNodeInfo` once, and iterating over the result to open connections (`CConman::OpenNetworkConnection`) on the same loop for all addresses.`CConnman::ConnectNode` only checks a single address, at random, when resolving from a hostname, and uses it to check whether we are already connected to it.
An example to test this would be calling:
```
bitcoin-cli addnode "127.0.0.1:port" add
bitcoin-cli addnode "localhost:port" add
```
And check how it allows us to perform both connections some times, and some times it fails.
The latter boils down to the same issue, but takes advantage of `onetry` bypassing the `CConnman::ThreadOpenAddedConnections` logic and calling `CConnman::OpenNetworkConnection` straightaway. A way to test this would be:
```
bitcoin-cli addnode "127.0.0.1:port" add
bitcoin-cli addnode "localhost:port" onetry
```
### Adding the same peer with two different, yet equivalent, addresses
The current implementation of `addnode` is pretty naive when checking what data is added to `m_added_nodes`. Given the collection stores strings, the checks at `CConnman::AddNode()` basically check wether the exact provided string is already in the collection. If so, the data is rejected, otherwise, it is accepted. However, ips can be formatted in several ways that would bypass those checks.
Two examples would be `127.0.0.1` being equal to `127.1` and `[::1]` being equal to `[0:0:0:0:0:0:0:1]`. Adding any pair of these will be allowed by the rpc command, and both will be reported as connected by `getaddednodeinfo`, given they map to the same `CService`.
This is less severe than the previous issue, since even tough both nodes are reported as connected by `getaddednodeinfo`, there is only a single connection to them (as properly reported by `getpeerinfo`). However, this adds redundant data to `m_added_nodes`, which is undesirable.
### Parametrize `CConnman::GetAddedNodeInfo`
Finally, this PR also parametrizes `CConnman::GetAddedNodeInfo` so it returns either all added nodes info, or only info about the nodes we are **not** connected to. This method is used both for `rpc`, in `getaddednodeinfo`, in which we are reporting all data to the user, so the former applies, and to check what nodes we are not connected to, in `CConnman::ThreadOpenAddedConnections`, in which we are currently returning more data than needed and then actively filtering using `CService.fConnected()`
ACKs for top commit:
jonatack:
re-ACK 0420f99f429ce2382057e101859067f40de47be0
kashifs:
> > tACK [0420f9](0420f99f42)
sr-gi:
> > > tACK [0420f9](0420f99f42)
mzumsande:
Tested ACK 0420f99f429ce2382057e101859067f40de47be0
Tree-SHA512: a3a10e748c12d98d439dfb193c75bc8d9486717cda5f41560f5c0ace1baef523d001d5e7eabac9fa466a9159a30bb925cc1327c2d6c4efb89dcaf54e176d1752
df69b22f2e3cc03764a582f29a16a36114f67e17 doc: improve documentation around connection limit maximums (Amiti Uttarwar)
adc171edf45ec90857d990b8ec570f3c8c2242b7 scripted-diff: Rename connection limit variables (Amiti Uttarwar)
e9fd9c0225527ec7727d2a7ccbdf028784aadc6c net: add m_max_inbound to connman (Amiti Uttarwar)
c25e0e05550426f29d79571368d90f63fb472b02 net, refactor: move calculations for connection type limits into connman (Amiti Uttarwar)
Pull request description:
This is joint work with amitiuttarwar.
This has the first few commits of #28463. It is not strictly a prerequisite for that, but has changes that in our opinion make sense on their own.
It improves the handling of maximum numbers for different connection types (that are set during init and don’t change after) by:
* moving all calculations into one place, `CConnMan::Init()`. Before, they were dispersed between `Init`, `CConnman::Init` and other parts of `CConnman`, resulting in some duplicated test code.
* removing the possibility of having a negative maximum of inbound connections, which is hard to argue about
* renaming of variables and doc improvements
ACKs for top commit:
amitiuttarwar:
co-author review ACK df69b22f2e3cc03764a582f29a16a36114f67e17
naumenkogs:
ACK df69b22f2e3cc03764a582f29a16a36114f67e17
achow101:
ACK df69b22f2e3cc03764a582f29a16a36114f67e17
Tree-SHA512: 913d56136bc1df739978de50db67302f88bac2a9d34748ae96763288d97093e998fc0f94f9b6eff12867712d7e86225af6128f4170bf2b5b8ab76f024870a22c
af0fca530e4d8311bcb24a14c416e5ad7c30ff78 netbase: use reliable send() during SOCKS5 handshake (Vasil Dimov)
1b19d1117ca5373a15313227b547ef4392022dbd sock: change Sock::SendComplete() to take Span (Vasil Dimov)
Pull request description:
The `Socks5()` function which does the SOCKS5 handshake with the SOCKS5 proxy sends bytes to the socket without retrying partial writes.
`send(2)` may write only part of the provided data and return. In this case the caller is responsible for retrying the operation with the remaining data. Change `Socks5()` to do that. There is already a method `Sock::SendComplete()` which does exactly that, so use it in `Socks5()`.
A minor complication for this PR is that `Sock::SendComplete()` takes `std::string` argument whereas `Socks5()` has `std::vector<uint8_t>`. Thus the necessity for the first commit. It is possible to do also in other ways - convert the data in `Socks5()` to `std::string` or have just one `Sock::SendComplete()` that takes `void*` and change the callers to pass `str.data(), str.size()` or `vec.data(), vec.size()`.
This came up while testing https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/27375.
ACKs for top commit:
achow101:
ACK af0fca530e4d8311bcb24a14c416e5ad7c30ff78
jonatack:
ACK af0fca530e4d8311bcb24a14c416e5ad7c30ff78
pinheadmz:
ACK af0fca530e4d8311bcb24a14c416e5ad7c30ff78
Tree-SHA512: 1d4a53d0628f7607378038ac56dc3b8624ce9322b034c9547a0c3ce052eafb4b18213f258aa3b57bcb4d990a5e0548a37ec70af2bd55f6e8e6399936f1ce047a
`send(2)` can be interrupted or for another reason it may not fully
complete sending all the bytes. We should be ready to retry the send
with the remaining bytes. This is what `Sock::SendComplete()` does,
thus use it in `Socks5()`.
Since `Sock::SendComplete()` takes a `CThreadInterrupt` argument,
change also the recv part of `Socks5()` to use `CThreadInterrupt`
instead of a boolean.
Easier reviewed with `git show -b` (ignore white-space changes).
`CConnman::GetAddedNodeInfo` is used both to get a list of addresses to manually connect to
in `CConnman::ThreadOpenAddedConnections`, and to report about manually added connections in
`getaddednodeinfo`. In both cases, all addresses added to `m_added_nodes` are returned, however
the nodes we are already connected to are only relevant to the latter, in the former they are
actively discarded.
Parametrizes `CConnman::GetAddedNodeInfo` so we can ask for only addresses we are not connected to,
to avoid passing useless information around.
Currently it is possible to add the same node twice when formatting IPs in
different, yet equivalent, manner. This applies to both ipv4 and ipv6, e.g:
127.0.0.1 = 127.1 | [::1] = [0:0:0:0:0:0:0:1]
`addnode` will accept both and display both as connected (given they translate to
the same IP). This will not result in multiple connections to the same node, but
will report redundant info when querying `getaddednodeinfo` and populate `m_added_nodes`
with redundant data.
This can be avoided performing comparing the contents of `m_added_addr` and the address
to be added as `CServices` instead of as strings.
The current `addnode` rpc command has some edge cases in where it is possible to
connect to the same node twice by combining ip and address requests. This can happen under two situations:
The two commands are run one right after each other, in which case they will be processed
under the same loop in `CConnman::ThreadOpenAddedConnections` without refreshing `vInfo`, so both
will go trough. An example of this would be:
```
bitcoin-cli addnode "localhost:port" add
```
A node is added by IP using `addnode "add"` while the other is added by name using
`addnode "onetry"` with an address that resolves to multiple IPs. In this case, we currently
only check one of the resolved IPs (picked at random), instead of all the resolved ones, meaning
this will only probabilistically fail/succeed. An example of this would be:
```
bitcoin-cli addnode "127.0.0.1:port" add
[...]
bitcoin-cli addnode "localhost:port" onetry
```
Both cases can be fixed by iterating over all resolved addresses in `CConnman::ConnectNode` instead
of picking one at random
